What women can do when they’re young to be happy later on

, ,

New evidence from famed happiness researcher Richard Easterlin shows that women are happier than men in early adulthood, but at age 41, this switches, and men are happier later in life. Easterlin says this gap comes from frustration over an inability to get married. Because most people want to be married, and if you want to be married but you can’t get married, you are unhappy.

Intuitively it makes sense that younger women marry more easily than younger men— young women are hot, and they are out-earning their male counterparts, while young men are suffering a masculinity crisis. However as everyone ages, the men earn more money and the women have flabby thighs.

But I don’t think the issue is, as Easterlin says, marriage. I think the real issue is children. Having kids complicates a woman’s life in ways that are not so difficult for men. It’s true that men today are more involved in parenting than ever before, but still, children affect women so much that they don’t start earning less than men until they have kids.

Here’s the deal with parenting: men believe they are doing a great job of parenting no matter what they’re doing, and women always think they could do better. So a woman does better in marriage and career early-on, but when she adds kids to the mix, her self-esteem is challenged (second-guessing her parenting) and her ability to support herself is challenged (she earns less money) and she becomes increasingly dissatisfied.

I’m sure a bunch of women will write to tell me that their kids are the love of their life. But don’t bother. Because I’m not saying women don’t love their kids, and maybe I am saying that the lack of happiness is precisely because women love their kids so much.

So here are three things to do if you’re a woman who wants to hedge against unhappiness in later life.

1. Don’t have kids. Daniel Gilbert (who has a son) has great research to show that kids do not make people happier. Kids give great joy but also wreak great havoc. People used to think there is something wrong with women who don’t want kids. But really, there is something wrong with people who tell you that their kids make them happier: they are lying. Of course, it might not be intentional. And anyway, we lie to ourselves about a lot of things that we can’t change. But stop thinking that everyone should have children. Maybe not.

2. Keep your career. In her book, Necessary Dreams, Anna Fels reports that women struggle to have careers when their children are young. But when the kids are older, the women who kept their careers throughout the early years of raising children are much happier than the women who gave up careers. This research does not, of course, take into account who was happy when they were going on a three-day business trip and leaving a one-year-old at home with the nanny. Also, keep in mind that quitting work to have kids and reentering the workforce later is not that difficult for moms today. So get back into the workforce as soon as you think your kids can handle it; the benefits will ripple throughout your life.

3. If you are divorced, get plastic surgery. I am convinced that a lot of the reason women are happier earlier in life is that women have more control over their destiny when they are better looking. We know that people who are better looking get treated better throughout life, and we know that younger women do better remarrying than older women. So women should get plastic surgery if they get divorced so that they can remarry faster.

I say this about divorced women, but to be honest, I’m not taking the advice. It rings true to me, but it’s hard advice to swallow. The incurable optimist in me tells me I’ll do fine getting remarried just by being me.

But then, that’s the trouble with all research—when it suggests a change you weren’t already excited about, you decide that it doesn’t apply to you. And I’m no exception.

141 replies
« Older Comments
  1. Anastasia
    Anastasia says:

    Interesting point of view, but sounds like a lot of bull shit. Why? Because I know many beautiful childless women with successful careers who are unhappy and many women with grown up children without careers, hot looks or husbands who are really happy. Why? Because happiness for women of older age comes from the feeling of being truly needed, especially after certain age. Plastic surgery can’t make your eyes shine. You know the difference if you saw older women who eyes truly shine. Someone who feels needed always live longer and happier life. You can probably find examples in your communities: special needs teacher, an artist/teacher, a coach of 85 who teach kids to play tennis, etc. Having an interest in life and willingness to share it with others can help to be happier at older age.

  2. Frippet
    Frippet says:

    Penelope, I’m a big fan and a regular reader but I’m really very upset that you are advocating plastic surgery as a recipe for happiness. Have you read The Beauty Myth?

  3. Susan Su
    Susan Su says:

    I STRONGLY disagree with the idea that one should undergo cosmetic enhancements – tooth veneers, a nose job, Botox, anything else – just to land a husband.

    As a career move, however, is another story.

    I don’t think I’d ever go under the knife to fix my sagging face or boobs, but I did recently have corrective jaw surgery to advance my too-small upper jaw, thus fixing an underbite (for the curious, photos on my site).

    People have unanimously told me that I look better now, with coworkers commenting that I’m no longer “clenching my jaw.” Well, guess what? I was never clenching my jaw in anger or frustration – that was just how I looked. Now that that’s changed, it DEFINITELY has an impact on how others – especially men – view and treat me.

    Since, in my tech startup at least, men are still the ones who rule, it’s been crucial to my success to master the art of image management.

    • Reality Check
      Reality Check says:

      Susan,
      You were cute enough before the surgery that I don’t think your appearance would matter too much for work.

      It’s true that good-looking people have an edge, but a much greater edge is a very productive person with a great attitude. This doesn’t mean doormat by any means, just someone who gets their work done and helps others succeed.

      I’ve already said it before in the comments, but I’ll say it again: no one – absolutely no one – likes selfish people. No matter how great looking you are or how qualified you may be, you’ll eventually piss everyone off and they’ll let you go.

  4. Susan Su
    Susan Su says:

    Hard work and talent are the givens.

    However, individuals’ hard work and talent can be overlooked if they are unattractive.

    Joe Biden would look more like a crook than a politician without that (somewhat excessively) bright set of porcelain veneers over his natural smile. I assume that is why he was encouraged to get them.

    As for me and my jaw surgery, I can report with certainty that the reactions at my office have been extremely positive, with some of the most blunt individuals flat out saying I look “waaay better.”

    In any case, I did not do it for their approval, I did it for my TMJ and obstructed airway ;) But, I won’t say that the cosmetic benefits are unwelcome.

  5. willie
    willie says:

    I disagree with everything.

    Why do you think that all men want fake boobs? I do not know of any man that wants to touch pumped up water balloons. Women save your money. Eat right, exercise, and get enough sleep. To attract a good man, be nice to him, smile, be unselfish, caring and treat a man like a man and not a little boy. Also if everyone took your advice about #1, our society may die, what do you think? I love my kids and cannot imagine being without them. From a Dad who is always trying harder to be a better Dad.

  6. RenaissanceTrophyWife
    RenaissanceTrophyWife says:

    Cosmetic surgery may be the answer for some people, but adverse consequences occur every day. You could end up dead on the table, or with a horrific aesthetic result/impaired functionality. If you listen to #1 before following #3, at least you won’t be leaving behind kids who may be scarred by the death of a parent.

    That said, #3 may also help land a man, but not necessarily the type of man you’d want to be married to. I think it’s good you’re not following your own advice, but I worry about women with low self-esteem (and aren’t as pretty as you) who may interpret your advice as a claim that cosmetic surgery can solve a multitude of problems.

  7. steve
    steve says:

    Isn’t true happiness about fulfillment, a sense of achieving what you believe to be your purpose for being on this earth.
    For the majority of people this means creating life. I don’t think the choice to have kids is very often made to provide a quick pick me up.
    Other people find enormous satisfaction in their careers and feel content that that is their purpose which is fine.It’s not like humanity is shrinking.

    I on the other hand do not have a rewarding career have never been financially secure and because of that I have never had kids. Am I happy? No I’m goddamn miserable!!

  8. Rebecca Gonzalez
    Rebecca Gonzalez says:

    I wanted to add my vote. This is my all time favorite post of 2008. I sent it to a couple of friends because I thought it so accurately described what they have been telling me about when describing their unhappiness. I am a very late 40’s working mother of one 10-year-old kid. Married. Pretty happy due to several things: only 1 kid which is pretty easy to manage with 2 parents; have worked the whole time but have had to be satisfied with certain things — like picking jobs close to hope vs. promotions; and finally mild plastic surgery. I truly believe all 3 things have led me to be more content then I would have been, given that I didn’t get married until 36. Meaning I had a life before being a wife and mother, and would have been very dissatisfied if I had walked away from said prior life. Anyway, great post and my vote for best of 2008. Happy New Year!

  9. Nan
    Nan says:

    I think people with bullshit paycheck slave jobs SHOULND’T have kids. Kids are expensive and we have too many people in this world anyways, plus raising children is difficult. People just have children because that’s the thing to do and that’s what they believe it’s expected of them when in reality it makes them miserable. I’m not saying people don’t love their children people do they love them more than anything in this world, but when you’re stuck having to work and not see your children then well you don’t have any business having kids!

  10. The Reporter
    The Reporter says:

    You do all of the above-mentioned things, no kids, career, etc., and then people can’t relate to you… and vice versa. 

    Connecting with people is more difficult if you can’t share in their misery.  People resent people who feel like they have all the answers.  Relating to others becomes the problem.  It’s a trade-off no matter how you look at it.  I know this because I’m a DINK….Double Income No Kids.

  11. Robin
    Robin says:

    A lot of women wouldn’t “need” plastic surgery if they took better care of themselves. Abstaining from smoking, alcohol, and recreational drugs was often a point of teasing in my youth, but I turn 35 in two weeks and everyone tells me I look ten years younger. Instead of the knife, invest in a allergist: so many skin problems occur when we eat & drink things that could cause a reaction. Total abstinance from makeup helps, too. Some jojoba oil to moisturize is all I need. Each woman needs to find what her body needs, and it might help you look better (notice I didn’t say ‘younger) later in life.
    Oh, and I never had kids, either.

    The weirdest thing though…I often see women who habitually wear high heels looking the worst. Maybe all that stress in the feet & legs ends up somewhere, after all.

« Older Comments

Comments are closed.