When I was growing up, there was lots of chatter in the media about how models gave girls bad role models. Today that’s old news. What we should talk about now is how the media portrays moms.
Take a look at the spread in People magazine of Jennifer Lopez and her one-month-old twins. The photos are so elegant that at first I thought it was a parody. But in fact, it is mommy porn: the visual fantasy of what being a working mom could be. And it really could be that, if it weren’t that someone like Jennifer Lopez must have a household full of helpers in order to keep her career on track while she has kids: a cook, a trainer, two or three nannies, a cleaner, an assistant, a stylist. And others I’m sure I can’t even imagine.
Here’s another example of mommy porn: Angelina Jolie, and her fifty kids. She has a rule that the nannies (plural, yes, each kid has their own) cannot be photographed holding the kids, because it’s bad for Angelina’s image as a mom. But this is the problem: It looks like these very successful women have it all, even though they don’t.
Here’s what happens: Some reporter interviews someone about their big job. And then the person ends up talking about the mythic work-life-balance topic. And they say something like, “Throughout my career I did [insert something that is supposed to be wonderful for children] for my kids.” And now, of course, we must assume that the kids are doing fine. But why do we believe that? Why do we even ask? We have no hope of learning the truth. After all, there are very few people in the world who are in a position to say that their career is, as they speak, harming their kids.
So journalists writing about moms being moms are not reporting the truth. It is propaganda. It is parents saying that they lived their lives in a way that was good for their kids. But really, who knows? The reporter has little ability to check. So all we’re left with is the parents giving their subjective and hugely biased opinion that their kids are turning out fine.
I’m not saying that every kid is messed up from their parents’ careers. I’m saying that I’m sick of learning about how famous families want us to think they are doing by looking at what is really only mommy porn, what is really just parenting propaganda.
So look, in the interest of truth-telling, I’m telling you this: people are not being honest about what it’s like to be with kids. People are scared to admit that they would rather be at work than with their kids, because work is easier than parenting. (Notable exception: Sally Krawcheck.) If I have to read about how much someone loves their kids one more time, I’m gonna puke. Because we all know that parents love their kids. It’s not interesting. It’s not helpful. It’s not even very relevant. For anyone.
What’s interesting is the part where parents love their kids but don’t love being with them on a daily basis. It’s very scary to write. But I’m telling you, if the feeling weren’t ubiquitous then there would be no one to be in middle management working 9-5 because they’d all be home with their kids, doing freelance work after bedtime.
People are choosing to go to work rather than stay with their kids all day. But no one talks about making this choice because they are scared their kids will read it. I’m not sure what the right answer is. I just know that somehow there has to be a more honest discussion of parenting in this world.
So with all the mommy porn, the media does a lot to make us think that work life balance is possible, in the same way anorexic bodies without treatment for anorexia is possible.
So there’s real damage from mommy porn. Everyone begins thinking that every woman should be parenting gracefully while working full time. This gives people the temerity to ask me, nearly every day: Who takes care of your kids?
That’s right. The genesis of this rant is that I was meeting with an investor — a guy in his early 40s — and we were talking about my travel schedule and he asked, “Who takes care of your kids?”
I told this to one of my board members and he said, “What??? Why did you answer that question?”
I said I answer it because I get the question every single day. Literally. And I don’t think twice about it anymore. But in fact, it’s a totally offensive question. Here’s how I’m so sure: I tried it out on Mr. Sales Guy. And even though Mr. Sales Guy and I work the same number of hours, he said something to the effect of, “I’m not really sure what goes on with the kids all day, you have to ask my wife.” He answered the question as if we were doing girl talk. As if I had asked him, “What brand of tampon does your wife use?”
So I want to tell you something: Women earn more than men in most major cities today. And in corporate America, up and down the ladder, women and men are on equal footing in the workplace in terms of who gets paid what, as long as neither party has kids. But the level of expectations people have for parenting is absolutely insane. The mommy porn feeds this problem. Everyone is drawn to the ideal of Angelina Jolie as the perfect combination of careerist and mother like the Pied Piper’s tune, and these attitudes are more exhausting to me than any amount of actual parenting ever is.
Subscribe — free! 

Don't do what you love
Don't go to grad school
Blueprint for a Woman's life
Living up to your potential is BS
Choose sex over money
5 Time management tricks I learned from years of hating Tim Ferriss (1013 comments)
I hate David Dellifield. The one from Ada, Ohio. (552 comments)
You can’t manage your work life if you can’t talk about it (764 comments)
The Farmer
Melissa
Penelope
While I do agree with *most* of your post… I take a lot of offense that women who choose to go to work do not love being at home with their children all day. I did stay home with both of mine, because it was easier, and I could. Then I worked 9 to 5 when my youngest was old enough to be weaned. Not because I didn’t love being at home, but because it made the most sense. I made more, and hubby CHOSE to be the at home parent. He loves it. I now work from home full time, so I can be both.
Some women work out of necessity to keep food on the table. Some women do work because they prefer it to all day parenting of their kids. Do not assume we do not love our children, because you will encounter some extremely irate women.
Posted by Junebug on August 4, 2008 at 1:08 pm | permalink |
Loving your children and wanting to be with them all day are two different things. Penelope said nothing about love.
Posted by Cherri Porter on November 16, 2011 at 7:35 am | permalink |
Mommie Porn – no kidding, we’re supposed to be perfect moms with perfect kids making perfect meals with perfect makeup. In a miniskirt.
Posted by cchiovitti on August 5, 2008 at 12:22 am | permalink |
That is THE most refreshing thing I’ve read since I got sucked into the blog world!
Posted by Aimee on September 13, 2008 at 6:59 pm | permalink |
On the subject of Mommy Porn (and ugh…I saw the Jennifer Lopez picture), what I really want to know is how many of these 40ish first time celebrity moms are aborting Down Syndrome kids? Are we to believe that the genetic abnormality just never visits them because they are so beautiful and popular? Or is this precisely why none wants to tell news of their pregnancy until after the first trimester?
Parenting is hard, but one gets acclimated. I even home school 3 girls! It is, after all, a great privilege, honor and delight if–like anything else–you work hard everyday to build the kind of work environment that you want.
Posted by Grafted Branch@Restoring the Years on September 14, 2008 at 12:11 am | permalink |
Why mommy porn? Why not mommy idealism or mommy unrealistic freaking expectations or –
So okay, mommy porn is easier to say and connotes the same meaning.
Posted by onufer on October 20, 2008 at 5:37 am | permalink |
I enjoyed reading your blog, but I guess I’m not the type of woman that enjoys reading these magazines celebs appear on. I don’t even watch TV (I rather much watch movies). I stay away from gossip blogs too.
So what I am basically saying is that I don’t know how these celeb mom’s look like or what exactly ‘mommy porn’ is. I just know that I am not trying to be like anyone. I had already set reasonable goals and expectations before I became a mother. I’m 24 now and I have a beautiful baby. I wish I could do everything under the sun for my new baby girl, but even with the so called time most people think a homemaker would have I just don’t have enough of it.
Posted by chicks on November 21, 2008 at 8:31 am | permalink |
As a part-time (or ‘shared care’) parent, I completely agree with your comment that it is hard to write about loving your kids but not loving being with them ALL the time. I strive to do this, as I think it is important to inspire and to reassure other parents who also experience difficulties, as well as the joys. Thank you for doing this so well.
Posted by Anna Colette (aka Part Mummy Part Me) on November 24, 2008 at 10:08 am | permalink |
I’ve got my pitchfork and torch! Who are we lynching again? Is it the magazine editor, the celeb, or the men?
The gentlemen who said that men do not subscribe to the idea that they have to be perfect or do it all was exactly right. It’s simply not realistic to think that you can have it all or do it all as a man/woman or a father/mother. Just roll your eyes and maybe have a good laugh at such ideas. In the meantime be the best parent/spouse you can be. Also know yourself and do what is best for the family (this includes yourself as well. Not just your spouse and kids.) Don’t let completely unrealistic crap in the media bother you. Just live in the real world instead.
Posted by top-post.ru on December 3, 2008 at 3:46 am | permalink |
As someone who has made the choice not to have kids, I have to say that the part that actually bothers me the most is that so many mothers I know talk about of both sides of their mouth:
On one hand, they are stressed, lonely at home, and unhappily doing the lion’s share of the domestic work while their husband’s lifestyle seems to have barely changed at all and they feel completely unable to say anything to most people for fear of being judged.
Only to then have them do the same to those of us who do not want to have kids, pointing out that life is incomplete without them and implying that we are somehow deluding ourselves that a life without kids is even worth living.
I think the most insidious thing about “Mommy Porn” isn’t so much that mothers eat it up, it’s that even knowing that it’s total crap, they still try to spoon feed it to the rest of us.
Posted by Alora on January 17, 2009 at 10:23 pm | permalink |
I totally agree with what you are talking about. You see these celebrities all the time on the television, or in the magazines with their children; smiling and looking like it is so easy to raise children, especially when they do have a lot of help. I have 2 children of my own and I can honestly say that I would rather be at a job because you are right it is easier to deal with other people then children. Don’t get me wrong I love my children with all my heart and would do anything for them, but i am home with them on a daily basis and sometimes I just wish I had an outside job.mothers at home
Posted by Shannon on February 19, 2009 at 9:06 pm | permalink |
I’ll tell you what, raising kids is one of the hardest things you will ever do. It also is probably one of the best things that ever happens to you, aside from getting married to your lifelong (hopefully) love.
Watching them grow up and deal with failure and success all at once and finally see them become the best of best at what they do, fulfilling their destinies is probably the best thing that can ever happen.
You’ll see, and at that moment you’ll be so proud you’ll wonder what else your kids could accomplish.
Posted by Suzie Harfnan on March 20, 2009 at 7:29 am | permalink |
parenting should not be for everyone…..i saw today i mother probably not even 23 years old, feeding her crying baby in a restaurant and not even touching the poor child, she was feeding the poor thing while it was seating on the high chair and she was on her phone
Posted by mr luggage on June 7, 2009 at 8:51 pm | permalink |
Amen, Penelope….and I just love that term “mommy porn”. It’s GREAT!
Posted by mysticaltyger on February 9, 2010 at 7:48 pm | permalink |
Frankly, I think the world would be a better place if everyone worked part-time (regardless of their parent status).
Posted by MLM Training on March 2, 2010 at 8:41 pm | permalink |
Mommy Porn. Love it!
Posted by [url=http://www.kapowphotography.co.uk]wedding photographer swansea[/url] on March 12, 2010 at 10:16 am | permalink |
Oops!
Posted by wedding photographer swansea on March 12, 2010 at 10:17 am | permalink |
there’s a lot of truth to this, but i have to say that i don’t think that “People are scared to admit that they would rather be at work than with their kids, because work is easier than parenting” in every case. i think a lot of people go back to work because they HAVE to and if given the choice would rather be at home with them.
Posted by amcclaran on March 16, 2010 at 9:28 pm | permalink |
Hmm. One day I hope that women and men can make meaningful choices in their own lives and not have to defend the decision to anyone. Children are great, and hard, and frustrating, and terrifying. Get through it with the best grace you can, love them, love yourself….and fu(* the rest.
Robin
Posted by Robin Perkins on August 23, 2010 at 2:13 am | permalink |
I love the term “mommy porn” and you are so right… If we could just all be honest about how god damn hard it is to be a parent, then I’m sure we’d see a lot less anxiety and anitdepressive medicine going over the counter…
The problem is that everyone is trying to live up to something that isn’t real… IMO.
Posted by Chris on September 5, 2010 at 10:48 am | permalink |
I had a job as a residence manager for a residence with 12 emotionally disabled women. The residence was a 24 hour fully supervised residence, and I was responsible for the residents and a staff of about 25 full and part-time workers.
I had to wear a beeper 24 hours a day, 7 days a week (this was before cellphones), and occasionally took clients who threatened to hurt themselves or others to the hospital. I dealt with client attacks, a grueling work schedule, and no free time.
And I’ll say it easily: when I quit work to take care of my then 8 month daughter(who broke her leg in two places at the babysitter-that’s another story altogether), IT WAS STILL HARDER TO BE AT HOME.
There is nothing like parenting: in addition to the general management skills you need to run a house, you need a certain amount of skill to be able to understand your children and know how to deal with the issues they have and the challenges they present.
I know a lot of moms who just can’t handle this level of intimacy being at home requires of them. So they make it look like being at work is glamorous and doable.
But I’ll say it again: I worked 10-12 hours a day with a nursing baby, and that was STILL easier than being at home. Not just easier, but more immediately satisfying in a way. You do a job, it gets done, and stays done. Your boss likes it, your coworkers notice or commiserate with you.
It takes courage, guts, and committment to be a stay-at-home. I think it’s about time for some Stay At Home Mommy Porn.
Posted by rachel on October 11, 2010 at 2:40 pm | permalink |
Great article. I get a hit of mommy porn in the doctors office while I wait for my doctor appointment. I went in to see the Doctor about my chronic fatigue I have had since about a year into my full-time job as a single full-time (sole custody) mother. He is telling me that I need exercise as the antidote to my fatigue, but with my work/parenting, there is no time and I am tired.
I was lied to and believed whole-heartedly that I could safely and would succeed as a single mom (by choice) and a professional working mom. My physical abilities have been de-conditioned. I never lost the weight put on by pregnancy so in addition to carrying the awkward weight of my child and the extra 50 lbs, I now suffer from all sorts of ailments: adult onset asthma, chronic cough, GERD, sway back pain brought on since working and raising a child by myself.
Having a weekly cleaner and daycare wasn’t enough. I just hired a homemaker (AKA wife) to assist the morning routine to have more relaxed time with my son in the morning and to have some down time while my son is still in daycare and I am off work. It’s expensive, but the truth is that raising kids takes two people and a good income.
My doctor’s diagnosis: I have not recovered from the process of child birth (my son is four) and that is reassuring for me. He wants me off work for 6 months. I think he should get rid of the mommy porn in his office!
Posted by Rainbow McBryan on March 8, 2011 at 12:15 pm | permalink |
The same narcissism that leads a person to believe he/she should be on physical display as some kind of physical ideal leads a person to make it appear he/she is an ideal parent with ideal work/life balance. Both are destructive the normal rest of us.
Posted by Paul on April 14, 2011 at 5:00 pm | permalink |
Seriously? Stop reading magazines, if that’s what you’re after, and read more blogs. I don’t read bloggers who romanticize parenthood because there’s nothing there for me. I read about other hardworking, confused, loving, stressed-out, often-bad-parenting parents because it gives me a reality check and a lifeline. And some laughs, which is really the only thing that can get you (and your kids) through family life.
Posted by Midianite Manna on November 15, 2011 at 9:40 pm | permalink |
Since you like research, here are some of my favorites:
Ask Moxie http://moxie.blogs.com/askmoxie/
Motherhood is not for Wimps http://damomma.com/ (although unfortunately she had to stop her amazing blogging to, you know, make money and raise kids)
And here’s my own post from earlier this year: http://midianitemanna.blogspot.com/2011/08/i-love-you-really-now-fuck-off.html
Posted by Midianite Manna on November 15, 2011 at 9:46 pm | permalink |